Skip to main content

Jordan Hall: Christianity as the Key to the Meta-Crisis

Date: 2025-09-01
Source: YouTube Transcript - "Jordan Hall: Is Christianity the Key to the Meta-Crisis?" by Mahon McCann
Type: External Content Summary

Core Thesis​

Jordan Hall argues that the meta-crisis is fundamentally a spiritual crisis requiring a return to authentic relationship with God rather than strategic solutions. The collapse of modernity and rise of digital technology creates a liminal space where only grounding in the sacred can provide proper orientation.

Key Insights on the Meta-Crisis​

The Nature of the Meta-Crisis​

"Categorically the heart of the metacrisis is in fact a religious crisis... you keep going down the stack when you get to the bottom of the stack you're like oh that's actually where it is."

"The proper way to think about it and by the way the proper way to respond to it is at the level of spiritual war."

Hall frames the meta-crisis as the natural death of secular institutional structures reaching their end point, comparing it to a 90-year-old experiencing cascading system failures. The crisis reveals underlying spiritual warfare that becomes visible when secular structures collapse.

The End of Modernity​

"We are reaching the end of actually the printing press and entering into the digital noticing that the modernity is derivative of the printing press."

"The meta crisis is the end of the regime of the printing press which is to say including the end of modernity the end of liberalism the end of the enlightenment."

Hall identifies the transition from print-based to digital culture as fundamental, arguing we're moving toward something resembling the medieval mind rather than continuing modern patterns.

The Sacred vs. Secular Distinction​

The Collapse of Sacred Categories​

"First it was just the sacred. We just had the notion of the sacred and we had the notion of the sacred as being present and fundamental. Meaning the sacred was not that cathedral and everything else wasn't sacred. The sacred was all of creation."

"As the sacred begins to evaporate, then we begin to see the residuum of what had once been held in and by the sacred start to become identified with its less sacred or mundane characteristics."

Hall traces how the sacred contracted from being omnipresent to isolated locations, eventually evaporating entirely and leaving only market/state dichotomies where the commons (sacred) once existed.

Digital Identity as Sacred​

"Digital identity is in the commons. Digital identity is grounded in the sacred... Who are you? Well, you are definitely not a subject of the state and you are definitely not an economic actor. You are a soul, right? You're a soul in the kingdom of God."

This represents a radical reframing of technological challenges as fundamentally theological rather than political or economic problems.

The Nature of Faith and Virtue​

Faith Redefined​

"When I say faith I do not mean maximally unevidenced belief... That is a defamation. That is in fact a lie... Faith is the boundary between the unconscious and the conscious threshold when properly ordered."

"Faith is the boundary between our capacity, our faculty for being in intimate, skillful, wholesome, effective, practical relationship with complex reality."

Hall reclaims faith from modern distortions, describing it as embodied competence for navigating reality that exceeds analytical capacity - like learning to ride a bike or speak fluently.

Virtue as Relational​

"Virtue is principally not at all your relationship with the social world. It is not even your relationship with other people. It's not even your relationship with yourself. It's your relationship with God."

"Virtue grows organically in the unfolding process of your increasingly intimate relationship with Christ and your increasingly intimate relationship with the body of Christ which are two faces of the same coin."

Virtue emerges from proper communion rather than individual moral effort, creating authentic integrity that can withstand secular pressures.

The Christian Response​

Surrender and Humility​

"What you discover at the very basis at the bottom of virtue is that your relationship with God must be one of surrender, one of humility, right? One of deep, deep gratitude."

"If you are still at the end of the day egoically addicted at the if at the end of the day you are requiring God to subordinate himself to your characterizations of reality then you're still stuck at zero."

The fundamental requirement is ego-death and genuine submission to divine authority rather than trying to fit God into human frameworks.

Everything Matters​

"You're on the hook for literally everything. Like, it's not you're on the hook for everything. Everything matters... your tone of voice, the way you comb your hair, it's the way you walk in the world, the way you breathe. I mean, everything matters."

Christianity creates total moral accountability while providing the grace and community structure to handle this responsibility through proper ordering.

No Strategy, Only Obedience​

"There is no selling. Okay. Um there is only telling the truth as best you can... showing up are you try to show up as you are called by God."

"How do you sell people on showing up as you're called by God? You show up as you're called by God. That's it."

Hall rejects all strategic approaches to evangelism or cultural change, advocating only authentic witness and obedience to divine guidance.

The Digital and the Divine​

Digital as Medieval Recovery​

"Something about the digital involves the recovery of the medieval not exclusively and certainly not completely but but meaningfully and and uh illustratively."

"We are reaching post literacy... A new image will emerge... We're working at something that is going to be much more like the medieval mind than it is like the modern mind."

The digital age enables participatory rather than propositional truth, making it more compatible with authentic Christianity than the modern mind.

The Divine Economy​

"What does it look like if you live in a world where people are taking their orders from God as it turns out it's incredibly compatible with the digital like shockingly remarkably compatible with the digital."

Hall envisions a post-crisis culture where divine guidance replaces strategic planning, enabled by digital technologies that support real relationship and accountability.

Church and Hierarchy​

Real vs. Formal Hierarchy​

"There is in fact a natural hierarchy and the hierarchies by the way flow... There's different roles and different people... The moment you're in has a proper hierarchy. You must become fluid enough to be oriented towards that proper hierarchy."

"A formal hierarchy is is how you get into the trouble of improper or usurped authority... there are real leaders... they have the cognitive capacity and the relational capacity to perceive the larger picture."

Hall distinguishes between authentic, situational leadership and institutionalized power structures, advocating for "spontaneous subordination" to real competence.

Ecclesiological Integration​

"What I've noticed over the past two years is that for somewhat obvious reasons, the Protestant sensibilities make a lot of sense to me... Orthodoxy has also made a lot of sense to me... Something I I haven't really been able to get a handle on on what is happening in the Catholic side of this story."

"The inclusion of all in a single body is the responsibility of the Catholic. That is in fact the biggest burden that is carried by that piece of the larger body is taking responsibility for how does all this come together into full unity."

Hall sees the three major Christian traditions as representing necessary aspects of church structure that must be integrated rather than competing.

Personal Transformation​

The Cost of Conversion​

"Life now has a very like it's a straight and narrow path. There's things that have to be done and they have to be done the way they have to be done and it has nothing to do with my preferences."

"I almost feel like I'm letting somebody down now. Like whereas before there was no there was no other in some sense... But God is so much more fundamental in that sense that like you kind of have you're yeah I don't know you're on the hook."

Both Hall and his interviewer describe the shock of genuine moral accountability after conversion, contrasting it with previous relativistic frameworks.

Growth in Holiness​

"A saint is somebody who has built a proper ordering of their life so that they are quite good and stable... their errors are pushed out to the edge. Their sins are pushed out to the edge."

"Every story I've ever heard of the saints is they're more painfully aware of the fact that as a circle increases, the circumference actually increases."

Sanctification involves ordering life properly around the most important relationships and responsibilities while remaining humble about remaining imperfections.

Conclusion​

Hall presents Christianity not as one option among many for addressing the meta-crisis, but as the only adequate response to civilizational collapse. The digital age paradoxically enables a return to pre-modern ways of being that are more compatible with authentic faith than modern rationalism. The path forward requires individual conversion leading to authentic community, which then becomes the foundation for renewed culture - but only through obedience to divine guidance rather than human strategy.

The conversation represents a sophisticated integration of systems thinking, spiritual theology, and cultural analysis that positions Christian conversion as both personally transformative and civilizationally necessary.